Welcome to La Sicilia Pizza Pasta Grille, a beloved gem nestled in the heart of Oxford, Pennsylvania. This family-friendly pizza restaurant, located at 58 S 3rd St, is more than just a place to grab a meal—it's a destination where friends and families gather to enjoy authentic Italian flavors. With a menu filled with tasty offerings ranging from handmade pizzas to hearty pasta dishes, La Sicilia captures the essence of Italian dining.
As I stepped into La Sicilia, the atmosphere instantly enveloped me with warmth and a hint of excitement. The tantalizing aroma of freshly baked pizza wafted through the air, setting the stage for a delightful culinary journey. Their pizza selections are sure to impress. Choose from sizes that cater to every appetite—from a small 12" with six slices perfect for solo snackers to a generous Sicilian pie that boasts a thick crust and sixteen slices, ideal for sharing. The gluten-free option ensures that everyone can join in the fun without compromise, using a cauliflower crust baked in the same ovens as regular pizzas.
What truly sets La Sicilia apart is the quality of its ingredients and the care taken in preparation. The extensive range of toppings, from pepperoni and sausage to more unique options, allows guests to create their perfect pizza. Not to be overlooked, the restaurant’s selection of hearty Stromboli and savory calzones is equally enticing, promising to satisfy even the most discerning palates.
When it comes to appetizers, La Sicilia does not hold back. Options like crispy mozzarella sticks and zesty fried calamari provide a tantalizing start to any meal. I personally couldn't resist the mega fries, a decadent combination of cheddar, mozzarella, bacon, and ranch—a must-try for comfort food lovers.
It’s not only the food that makes La Sicilia special; it’s the people who bring it to life. The staff, led by passionate individuals like Victor Mascali, ensure that every visit is memorable. Guests rave about the attentive service and the personal touches offered by the team. From organizing special events to providing exceptional dining experiences, the commitment to customer satisfaction is clear.
Whether you're celebrating a milestone like a birthday or simply looking for a cozy night out, La Sicilia Pizza Pasta Grille invites you to indulge in their flavorful offerings. With a menu that balances tradition and innovation, backed by a service crew that treats you like family, La Sicilia stands out as a must-visit dining spot in Oxford, PA.
In conclusion, if you're searching for a place that embodies the heart of Italian hospitality and serves up generous portions of deliciousness, look no further than La Sicilia Pizza Pasta Grille. You’ll leave not only satisfied but eager to return for more!
Your insights help other diners decide. We’ll keep your email private. Required fields are marked *
Parker Large
28/09/2025
Victor Mascali made my night. The moment I entered the restaurant I was immediately fulfilled by the mere presence of Victor Mascali. He seated me in an instant and delivered my beverage. I ordered the steak and after being perfectly grilled by Victor Mascali, I consumed it leaving no crumbs. Victor Mascali took note of my every need, providing refills and excellent service during the busiest of times. Victor Mascali is the embodiment of what true passion in the workplace looks like. Victor Mascali is the manifestation of perfection. I never leave reviews, however Victor Mascali’s performance compelled me to write this. To Victor Mascali: thank you for your time and I will return again to see you.
D
24/09/2025
The food is pretty good. I would say above average. The prices are competitive, and the people are very friendly when you go in to pick stuff up. I’ve eaten here several times over the past few years and everything I’ve gotten has been pretty good.
Jacquelyn Pierce
14/08/2025
I've been wanting to write this review for a while but hadn't gotten to it until now. A little over a month ago was my 30th birthday and I was having a party. My original venue didn't work out last minute, even after I had sent out invitations and gotten RSVPs. Someone suggested I try La Sicilia as I was in a panic and unable to find a place within budget that had all we needed. I called La Sicilia exactly one week before my party and the owner was so understanding and kind, easy to work with!She got back to me(had to check on event staffing) within an hour - she said she could do it. I was beyond excited that we found a place to hold the party. I had never been to La Sicilia and have never seen the back room, I was only going off of photos online and what people have said. I went in the next day to make a deposit and sign a contract - again everyone was so kind. The day of the party I walked in and I was in awe! The banquet room was more beautiful that I could even imagine! We were able to decorate and they put black linens with gold napkins (black and gold were the party colors) and the tables looked beautiful! The room looked brand new- as if no one had ever been in there- super clean, fresh and bright. The staff working our party were amazing!! They were so helpful, kind and friendly, my family loved them. The food- SO GOOD! My original venue we were going to have bar food - La Sicilia's choices were WAY BETTER. We had chicken picata and penne a la vodka- best I ever had! And on each table was their homemade bruschetta that everyone loved! I even had one family member who is gluten free and couldn't have anything, they brought her out a GF dish just for her - unexpected and amazing! She loved it and was so grateful!! As was I!! The kids were able to get chicken fingers and fries too! The venue was BYOB - this wasn't the original plan ( we planned for open bar) but they had everything we needed, cooler, ice and soft drinks available. We brought big packs of things for people to drink (alcohol) and non drinkers had their choice of drink which was PERFECT! At the end of the night the owners chatted with us and we told them how great it was! Definitely plan on booking more events with La Sicilia and you should too! And we'll definitely be eating there more often! Thank you La Sicilia and their incredible staff!!
Jim “The Cheesesteak Guy” Pappas
27/07/2025
Nice place, hardy sandwich and under $9. I got the cheese steak with broccoli rabe and provolone cheese. The broccoli rabe was okay. Good amount and melt of provolone cheese. Good Choice if you find yourself in Oxford, PA. Plenty of tables, bathroom and TVs.